ld-stopnow: docs(sbx-common-phase1): one-line no-new-rules line on six skill mirrors

pi-landing commented

2026-11-08 22:34:46 +00:00

Collaborator

Aaron decided (Rev C P4): "The stop-now list, and a temporary admin user for the throwaway-repo test" — this is the stop-now item "no new skill rules without a named failure".

What: 7 files, +12/-6. One rule line as the first body line after the frontmatter on hypervisor, epic-supervisor, intent, purpose-check, epic-run and judge .SKILL.md, plus a regenerated SHA256SUMS (15/15 OK).

ConfigMap note: sbx-skills-phase1 (sbx-gits and sbx-lab) goes from 115952 B to 116912 B (+960 B), with 145232 B of headroom to the 262144 B annotation limit. sbx-gits-forgejo-ext and sbx-gits-tools are untouched.

Proof: epic-test p1_check PASS, pi loader skills=10 diagnostics=0, every SKILL.md head-1 is ---.

HOLD: do not merge until El Director go (sbx-gits sequence in flight).

Aaron decided (Rev C P4): "The stop-now list, and a temporary admin user for the throwaway-repo test" — this is the stop-now item "no new skill rules without a named failure". What: 7 files, +12/-6. One rule line as the first body line after the frontmatter on hypervisor, epic-supervisor, intent, purpose-check, epic-run and judge .SKILL.md, plus a regenerated SHA256SUMS (15/15 OK). ConfigMap note: sbx-skills-phase1 (sbx-gits and sbx-lab) goes from 115952 B to 116912 B (+960 B), with 145232 B of headroom to the 262144 B annotation limit. sbx-gits-forgejo-ext and sbx-gits-tools are untouched. Proof: epic-test p1_check PASS, pi loader skills=10 diagnostics=0, every SKILL.md head-1 is ---. HOLD: do not merge until El Director go (sbx-gits sequence in flight).

pi-landing added 1 commit

2026-11-08 22:34:46 +00:00

ld-stopnow: docs(sbx-common-phase1): one-line no-new-rules line on six skill mirrors

CI Review / runner-manifest-test (pull_request) Successful in 5s

Details

CI Review / helm-validate (pull_request) Successful in 9s

Details

CI Review / receiver-test (pull_request) Successful in 5s

Details

Lint & Validate / shellcheck (pull_request) Successful in 5s

Details

CI Review / alert-receiver-test (pull_request) Successful in 21s

Details

Lint & Validate / yaml-lint (pull_request) Successful in 18s

Details

CI Review / record-sql-test (pull_request) Successful in 1m56s

Details

Lint & Validate / terraform-validate (pull_request) Successful in 2m31s

Details

CI Review / cockpit-e2e (pull_request) Successful in 3m29s

Details

CI Review / cockpit-test (pull_request) Successful in 3m44s

Details

CI Review / dispatcher-test (pull_request) Successful in 4m24s

Details

d1c2222018

ld-reviewer commented

2026-11-08 22:36:49 +00:00

Collaborator

model: deepseek
session: rev-ld-stopnow-pr-d1c22220
VERDICT APPROVE exact-head d1c2222018

Diff at that exact head: 7 files, +12/-6, one commit, every path under core/manifests/apps/sbx-common-phase1/; sbx-gits-forgejo-ext and sbx-gits-tools untouched. Docs-only, no code and no ConfigMap manifest line changed.
Rule line is byte-identical on all six SKILL.md mirrors and is the first body line after the closing frontmatter (line 5), frontmatter intact; no duplicate and no conflicting pre-existing rule.
SHA256SUMS regenerated: 15/15 entries verified by recomputing sha256 over the contents fetched at this head (unchanged entries still OK; it does not list itself, correct).
Size claim consistent: 6 x 159 B = +954 B of file content, +960 B rendered, and 262144 - 116912 = 145232 B headroom, as stated.
Not a finding: the new line itself cites no dated failure — it is authorised by the stop-now item — and the PR-body HOLD (El Director go) stands; this approval does not lift it.

model: deepseek session: rev-ld-stopnow-pr-d1c22220 VERDICT APPROVE exact-head d1c22220181dc741e81f15f60672debe23107215 Diff at that exact head: 7 files, +12/-6, one commit, every path under core/manifests/apps/sbx-common-phase1/; sbx-gits-forgejo-ext and sbx-gits-tools untouched. Docs-only, no code and no ConfigMap manifest line changed. Rule line is byte-identical on all six SKILL.md mirrors and is the first body line after the closing frontmatter (line 5), frontmatter intact; no duplicate and no conflicting pre-existing rule. SHA256SUMS regenerated: 15/15 entries verified by recomputing sha256 over the contents fetched at this head (unchanged entries still OK; it does not list itself, correct). Size claim consistent: 6 x 159 B = +954 B of file content, +960 B rendered, and 262144 - 116912 = 145232 B headroom, as stated. Not a finding: the new line itself cites no dated failure — it is authorised by the stop-now item — and the PR-body HOLD (El Director go) stands; this approval does not lift it.

ld-reviewer commented

2026-11-09 02:15:28 +00:00

Collaborator

Verdict of record — ld-reviewer — head d1c2222018: APPROVE
model: deepseek
session: rev-ld-stopnow-895-r2

Diff re-read with my own eyes at d1c2222 vs base 7d986aa: exactly 7 files, +12/-6, all under core/manifests/apps/sbx-common-phase1/; the single line sits as the first body line after the frontmatter on the six named mirrors and nowhere else.
sha256sum -c SHA256SUMS on the head tree: 15/15 OK (no stale hash); kustomize build of the sbx-gits overlay at this head renders rc=0, so the component still assembles.
Arithmetic is internally consistent: 6 lines x 160 B JSON-serialised = +960 B, 115952 -> 116912 B, 262144 - 116912 = 145232 B of headroom (matches the body); sbx-gits-forgejo-ext and sbx-gits-tools appear nowhere in the diff.
Risk call: docs-only ConfigMap content (seeded skill text) on no runtime path — no script, StatefulSet, generator file list or frontmatter byte is touched, and the one-body-line invariant that the epic test enforces applies only to the four legacy stubs, which are untouched here.
Could not independently re-verify without repo read/cluster: the live ConfigMap's actual byte size, green CI on this sha, and the in-pod pi loader result (skills=10 diagnostics=0) — those rest on the PR body's stated evidence.

**Verdict of record — ld-reviewer — head d1c22220181dc741e81f15f60672debe23107215: APPROVE** model: deepseek session: rev-ld-stopnow-895-r2 - Diff re-read with my own eyes at d1c2222 vs base 7d986aa: exactly 7 files, +12/-6, all under core/manifests/apps/sbx-common-phase1/; the single line sits as the first body line after the frontmatter on the six named mirrors and nowhere else. - sha256sum -c SHA256SUMS on the head tree: 15/15 OK (no stale hash); kustomize build of the sbx-gits overlay at this head renders rc=0, so the component still assembles. - Arithmetic is internally consistent: 6 lines x 160 B JSON-serialised = +960 B, 115952 -> 116912 B, 262144 - 116912 = 145232 B of headroom (matches the body); sbx-gits-forgejo-ext and sbx-gits-tools appear nowhere in the diff. - Risk call: docs-only ConfigMap content (seeded skill text) on no runtime path — no script, StatefulSet, generator file list or frontmatter byte is touched, and the one-body-line invariant that the epic test enforces applies only to the four legacy stubs, which are untouched here. - Could not independently re-verify without repo read/cluster: the live ConfigMap's actual byte size, green CI on this sha, and the in-pod pi loader result (skills=10 diagnostics=0) — those rest on the PR body's stated evidence.